P1Critical
Member experience leakage
Users who have paid still see ads, pop-ups for the plan they already own, and get sales calls.
Hurts: Renewal rate, reviews, refunds
Felt by: ET Prime members, most of all multi-year buyers; then renewals.
- Members report full-screen and video ads, and launch pop-ups for the plan they already bought, while the paywall promises "90% less ads".
- In 133 recent negative Google Play reviews of the ET app, 16 are about ads and 10 about being asked to subscribe when already subscribed.
- 28 complaints about sales calls across the four app samples in 12 months, some after cancelling.
See the fixes for P1 →
P2Critical
Access and billing failures
Some paying members are locked out of what they bought, charged twice, or have to email to get an invoice.
Hurts: Renewal rate, support cost, regulatory risk
Felt by: new and renewing members, the care team; regulators watch this.
- Members locked out of Prime stories, AI audio or ePaper; one paid ₹2,599 for a year and was charged ₹2,599 again a month later.
- Invoices only by emailing the care desk; reviewers waiting 21 to 30+ days. No refund policy.
- Users say cancelling auto-pay means emailing; the FAQ says it is in My Subscriptions. The RBI's 2026 rules for automatic payments (e-mandates) let a customer cancel that permission any time.
- 129 of 133 recent negative ET app reviews got the same templated reply.
See the fixes for P2 →
P3High
Offer sprawl and price inconsistency
There are many offers at once, and the website, the apps and TOI+ contradict each other on price and on what is included.
Hurts: Checkout conversion, discounting
Felt by: first-time buyers comparing offers; the business, which gives away discounts it did not need to.
- Nine different places on the mobile site ask you to buy or upgrade; one Prime paywall holds 12 buttons.
- A "Get Free Trial" badge on the home page, while the FAQ says there is no trial.
- TOI+ sells the same ETPrime stories and tools at the same ₹2,699; the HTML of the old plans page still carries coupon terms that expired in 2023.
See the fixes for P3 →
P4High
Low paid conversion and an audience gap
ET has half of Moneycontrol's audience and a much smaller paying base, at a much higher entry price.
Hurts: Subscription and ad revenue
Felt by: the business, in both ad and subscription revenue.
- About 1.75 lakh ET Prime subscribers (Crisil, June 2025) against the 10 lakh+ Moneycontrol Pro announced in October 2024: different sources and dates, but a wide gap. ET's own "10 Lakh+ members" claim is not reconciled with Crisil's count.
- Moneycontrol Pro starts at ₹499 a year in-app; ET Prime is ₹2,399 to ₹3,199 a year in-app.
- Advertising is 65 to 70% of Times Internet's revenue, and Crisil flags "continued weak operating profitability".
See the fixes for P4 →
P5High
Page performance and ad density
The mobile site is heavy, slow to load and crowded with ads, starting above the first headline.
Hurts: Readers leaving after one page, search ranking, ad value
Felt by: every mobile reader; advertisers, whose ads are seen less; search ranking.
- The home page makes a phone download 1,364 files from 285 other sites, takes 25.5 seconds to finish loading and carries 14 ads.
- A blank reserved ad slot fills about a third of the first phone screen above the headline.
- Google's speed score on a phone: Markets 29 out of 100, a Prime article 35 (the page jumps as it loads), and the checkout 34, with its main content taking 19.6 seconds.
See the fixes for P5 →
P6High
Acquisition concentration risk
A large share of new readers arrive from Google, and Google is sending fewer every year.
Hurts: New readers, new subscribers
Felt by: the business, the newsroom, every future subscriber.
- Google Search referrals to publishers fell 40.2% in a year; AI chatbots send 0.01% of traffic.
- Semrush estimates ET's visits fell from 64.6M in July to 49.2M in September 2026.
- Zerodha Pulse, a free aggregator from the broker, shows ET headlines alongside other publishers'.
See the fixes for P6 →
P7High
Feature regression and data trust
ET Markets removed a portfolio tracker some investors had used for years, and some report prices that are not up to date.
Hurts: Investor engagement, the value of Prime
Felt by: active investors, members who bought ET Prime for the tools.
- The ET Portfolio tracker went around June 2026 with no notice and no export; 19 of 79 recent negative ET Markets reviews mention it.
- Complaints of prices that are not real-time and old "buy" calls still shown.
- Seven crash or not-opening reviews of ET Markets on iOS between 8 and 11 Oct 2026.
See the fixes for P7 →
P8Medium
Notification routing and alert fatigue
Tapping a notification can open the home page instead of the story, and readers get more alerts than they asked for.
Hurts: Daily readers, retention
Felt by: daily readers; retention.
- Tapping a notification opens the home page and the story is gone (several reports, Nov 2025 to Jul 2026).
- Notification and email volume that ignores unsubscribes; forced weekly updates.
- The home page's "Top Prime Articles" widget still links 2023 stories.
See the fixes for P8 →