Independent study by Anchit Tandon, who worked on ET Prime and ET Markets at Times Internet until April 2026. Uses public information only; career figures are as published on my portfolio. Not affiliated with The Economic Times or Times Internet.
ET StudyProblems
The problems

Eight problems, ranked by who they hurt and how much

P1Critical

Member experience leakage

Users who have paid still see ads, pop-ups for the plan they already own, and get sales calls.

Hurts: Renewal rate, reviews, refunds

Felt by: ET Prime members, most of all multi-year buyers; then renewals.

  • Members report full-screen and video ads, and launch pop-ups for the plan they already bought, while the paywall promises "90% less ads".
  • In 133 recent negative Google Play reviews of the ET app, 16 are about ads and 10 about being asked to subscribe when already subscribed.
  • 28 complaints about sales calls across the four app samples in 12 months, some after cancelling.
See the fixes for P1 →
P2Critical

Access and billing failures

Some paying members are locked out of what they bought, charged twice, or have to email to get an invoice.

Hurts: Renewal rate, support cost, regulatory risk

Felt by: new and renewing members, the care team; regulators watch this.

  • Members locked out of Prime stories, AI audio or ePaper; one paid ₹2,599 for a year and was charged ₹2,599 again a month later.
  • Invoices only by emailing the care desk; reviewers waiting 21 to 30+ days. No refund policy.
  • Users say cancelling auto-pay means emailing; the FAQ says it is in My Subscriptions. The RBI's 2026 rules for automatic payments (e-mandates) let a customer cancel that permission any time.
  • 129 of 133 recent negative ET app reviews got the same templated reply.
See the fixes for P2 →
P3High

Offer sprawl and price inconsistency

There are many offers at once, and the website, the apps and TOI+ contradict each other on price and on what is included.

Hurts: Checkout conversion, discounting

Felt by: first-time buyers comparing offers; the business, which gives away discounts it did not need to.

  • Nine different places on the mobile site ask you to buy or upgrade; one Prime paywall holds 12 buttons.
  • A "Get Free Trial" badge on the home page, while the FAQ says there is no trial.
  • TOI+ sells the same ETPrime stories and tools at the same ₹2,699; the HTML of the old plans page still carries coupon terms that expired in 2023.
See the fixes for P3 →
P4High

Low paid conversion and an audience gap

ET has half of Moneycontrol's audience and a much smaller paying base, at a much higher entry price.

Hurts: Subscription and ad revenue

Felt by: the business, in both ad and subscription revenue.

  • About 1.75 lakh ET Prime subscribers (Crisil, June 2025) against the 10 lakh+ Moneycontrol Pro announced in October 2024: different sources and dates, but a wide gap. ET's own "10 Lakh+ members" claim is not reconciled with Crisil's count.
  • Moneycontrol Pro starts at ₹499 a year in-app; ET Prime is ₹2,399 to ₹3,199 a year in-app.
  • Advertising is 65 to 70% of Times Internet's revenue, and Crisil flags "continued weak operating profitability".
See the fixes for P4 →
P5High

Page performance and ad density

The mobile site is heavy, slow to load and crowded with ads, starting above the first headline.

Hurts: Readers leaving after one page, search ranking, ad value

Felt by: every mobile reader; advertisers, whose ads are seen less; search ranking.

  • The home page makes a phone download 1,364 files from 285 other sites, takes 25.5 seconds to finish loading and carries 14 ads.
  • A blank reserved ad slot fills about a third of the first phone screen above the headline.
  • Google's speed score on a phone: Markets 29 out of 100, a Prime article 35 (the page jumps as it loads), and the checkout 34, with its main content taking 19.6 seconds.
See the fixes for P5 →
P6High

Acquisition concentration risk

A large share of new readers arrive from Google, and Google is sending fewer every year.

Hurts: New readers, new subscribers

Felt by: the business, the newsroom, every future subscriber.

  • Google Search referrals to publishers fell 40.2% in a year; AI chatbots send 0.01% of traffic.
  • Semrush estimates ET's visits fell from 64.6M in July to 49.2M in September 2026.
  • Zerodha Pulse, a free aggregator from the broker, shows ET headlines alongside other publishers'.
See the fixes for P6 →
P7High

Feature regression and data trust

ET Markets removed a portfolio tracker some investors had used for years, and some report prices that are not up to date.

Hurts: Investor engagement, the value of Prime

Felt by: active investors, members who bought ET Prime for the tools.

  • The ET Portfolio tracker went around June 2026 with no notice and no export; 19 of 79 recent negative ET Markets reviews mention it.
  • Complaints of prices that are not real-time and old "buy" calls still shown.
  • Seven crash or not-opening reviews of ET Markets on iOS between 8 and 11 Oct 2026.
See the fixes for P7 →
P8Medium

Notification routing and alert fatigue

Tapping a notification can open the home page instead of the story, and readers get more alerts than they asked for.

Hurts: Daily readers, retention

Felt by: daily readers; retention.

  • Tapping a notification opens the home page and the story is gone (several reports, Nov 2025 to Jul 2026).
  • Notification and email volume that ignores unsubscribes; forced weekly updates.
  • The home page's "Top Prime Articles" widget still links 2023 stories.
See the fixes for P8 →
In readers' own words

What members and investors are saying

I analysed 1,973 reviews, 1,673 on Google Play (827 of the ET app, 846 of ET Markets) and 300 on the App Store, newest first, and keyword-counted the themes in the 1 and 2 star ones from the last 12 months. Quoted verbatim, including typos; names left out.

"Despite a 5 year paid subscription I continue to see ads in the articles. initially it was static images, now it is noisy distracting video ads."
ET app, Google Play · 2★ · 31 May 2026 · P1
"Every time I want to read a so called Prime article it prompts to subscribe, even though I'm already a subscriber."
ET app, Google Play · 1★ · 28 Oct 2026 · P1, P2
"I have subscribed for One year with the payment of Rs 2599. After one month again Deducted Rs 2599(because auto payment was enabled)."
ET app, Google Play · 1★ · 28 Dec 2025 · P2
"Their sales team is constantly pestering me to purchase the premium version through constant calls from different numbers."
ET app, Google Play · 1★ · 8 Jun 2026 · P1
"my 20 years of portfolio vanished in 1 day due to incompetence of ET Market Team."
ET Markets, Google Play · 2★ · 16 Jun 2026 · P7
"Even after 21 days from the date of purchase, the invoice has not been issued."
ET app, Google Play · 1★ · 6 Feb 2026 · P2
"When you click on a particular notification, it will navigate you to home page. And the particular news is vanished."
ET app, Google Play · 1★ · 3 Jun 2026 · P8
"on every screen possible paid members have to dismiss two full screen pop-up ads by Times Network one after another"
ET app, App Store · 1★ · 19 Mar 2026 · P1
Theme in 1 to 2 star reviews, last 12 monthsET app, Play (133)ET Markets, Play (79)ET app, iOS (63)
Ads and pop-ups, often from paying users1628
Paid but asked to subscribe, or locked out1028
Sales calls1297
Portfolio tracker removed or broken7191
Crash, hang or will not open968
Billing: double debit, auto-renew, invoice, refund811

Keyword counts, so indicative: one review can hit several themes. Reddit and X could not be read from my test environment, so they are not counted.

Root causes

Why the same problems keep coming back

Three causes behind the eight problems, as seen from outside.

No one visibly owns "the member"

From the outside, it looks as if ads, subscription, sales, the apps and TOI+ each optimise their own number. A member therefore shows up as ad inventory to one system, a lead to another and a lapsed account to a third. Behind: P1 member experience leakage; P2 access and billing failures; P3 offer sprawl and price inconsistency.

The first sale is visible, the second is not

Bonus-month bundles, callbacks and Diwali sales all aim at acquisition. Renewal, the thing that pays for it, has no visible owner: no value receipt, no self-serve invoice, a templated reply to every complaint. Behind: P1 member experience leakage; P2 access and billing failures; P4 low paid conversion and an audience gap.

Reach is rented, not owned

Search brings readers in and ad-heavy pages monetise them once. With search falling, ET needs a daily reason to come back that it controls: a watchlist, a briefing, a notification that works. Behind: P5 page performance and ad density; P6 acquisition concentration risk; P7 feature regression and data trust; P8 notification routing and alert fatigue.